Skip to content

Office of the Research Integrity Officer

Reusing Online
Materials in Research

 

The Basics   Beyond the Basics   Contact

 

Original works that are found online – including photographs, illustrations, templates, documents, fonts, and other materials – can be helpful to use in presentations, grants, and manuscripts. While online materials are very accessible, the rules and laws protecting these materials can be difficult to navigate. How do you know if you are allowed to use online materials that have been created by someone else?

The Basics 

What to consider before using online materials.

Copyright protects authors and creators by giving them the exclusive right to reproduce, create derivative works, distribute copies, and publicly display or perform original works1. In other words, when someone creates something original and tangible, they automatically own the copyright, and they get to choose how the work is used or reused. 

Authors can also choose to protect original works using creative commons licenses that allow for creators to set rules for reuse. They can also enter works into the public domain where they are no longer protected by copyright2.  

To reuse a creative work, one of the following criteria must be satisfied:

  • You get written permission from the copyright holder to use the work
    • If a work is made within the course and scope of employment, the employer owns the copyright.
  • You are using the work in a way that qualifies as fair use
  • The creator has chosen a creative commons license for the work, and you follow the reuse rules set by the creator
  • The work is otherwise in the public domain

It’s important to note that copyright only protects human created works and does not protect AI generated works. 

Companies and organizations can be copyright holders. If you make a creative work while working at an organization, the organization may own the copyright. At the University of Utah copyright ownership differs based on your role3: 

  • Staff and Non-faculty Academic Employees: Works created within the scope of employment at the University of Utah are owned by the University.
  • Faculty: Faculty generally own the copyright to works they make that are the result of teaching, research, scholarly, artistic pursuits, and/or traditional scholarly works unless the work was developed with substantial use of University resources and commercial use is made of the work.
  • Students: Students own the copyright of works that they create, as students, including dissertations, publications, and texts. 

If you publish an original work in a journal, the journal will own the copyright. If you publish a paper and want to reuse figures, you must first request permission from the publisher.

Click image to enlarge


A decision tree for best practices for resusing online materials in research. The tree has blue, yellow, green, and pink boxes with text for each level of the tree.  Are you the original creator of this work? Did you make it? If Yes: Proceed to 2.  If No: Proceed to 4.  Do you own the copyright of the work?  If Yes: No permission is needed.  If No: Proceed to 3.  Assess reuse for fair use.  If Yes: No permission needed because reuse is considered fair use.  If No: Ask Permission  Identify the original creator. Did the creator use a creative commons license or is the work in the public domain?  If Yes: Proceed to 5 and 6.  If No: Proceed to 7  If they used a creative commons license, follow the rules for reuse set by the creator.  If the work is in the public domain, it can be used freely.  The work is copyright protected. Has the Univeristy of Utah library licensed the work?  If Yes: No permission needed. You already have permission through the library if your use is within the scope of the University of Utah’s license  If No: Proceed to 8.  Assess reuse for fair use. If Yes: No permission needed because reuse is considered fair use.  If No: Ask permission. There is a box at the bottom of the decision tree with additional considerations: • Cite and provide attribution when using materials that you did not make • Consider asking for permission regardless if you need it • Reach out to Allyson Mower for assistance with fair use evaluations • Remember that if you use generative AI, disclose how you used    it and cite the model and the developer • AI generated works are not protected under U.S copyright law.

Beyond the Basics  

How to identify and evaluate more complex reuse situations.

Copyright1: Copyright protects authors and creators by giving them the exclusive right to reproduce, create derivative works, distribute copies, and publicly display or perform original works at the time of creation. Copyright makes it illegal for someone to reuse an original work in a way that violates the exclusive rights of the creator/author. 

Creative Commons2: Creative Commons licenses allow creators to give others the right to reproduce, create derivative works, distribute copies, and publicly display their works. There are different types of creative commons licenses that distinguish how creators want their work to be shared and if they permit the work to be reused for commercial purposes. To avail yourself of the protections of a creative commons license, you must read and comply with its terms (e.g. attribution, share alike, etc.)

Public Domain4: Works in the public domain are no longer under copyright protection. These works can be used without restrictions without permission of the original author or creator. Attribution is not required. 

Copyright protects authors and creators by giving them the exclusive right to reproduce, create derivative works, distribute copies, and publicly display or perform original works at the time of creation. Copyright makes it illegal for someone to reuse an original work in a way that violates the exclusive rights of the creator.   Creative Commons Creative Commons licenses allow creators to give others the right to reproduce, create derivative works, distribute copies, and publicly display their works. There are different types of creative commons licenses that distinguish how creators want their work to be shared and if they permit the work to be reused for commercial purposes.  Public Domain  Works in the public domain are no longer under copyright protection. These works can be used without restrictions without permission of the original author or creator. Attribution is not required, but highly encouraged.

Creative Commons License Types

Creative commons licenses use a combination of symbols to display the rules set by creators for reuse. Creators specify their requirements for attribution, commercial use, and adaptations. The different creative commons symbols are defined in the “Symbol Legend” below, with reuse meanings provided for the various symbol combinations.

Symbol Legend - BY: Credit must be given to the creator NC: Only noncommercial uses of the work are permitted SA: Adaptations or derivative works must be shared under the same terms ND: No derivatives or adaptations of the work are permitted Creative Commons License Types  CC BY: Credit must be given to the creator CC BY-SA: Credit must be given to the creator, Adaptations or derivative works must be licensed under an identical CC license CC BY-NC: Credit must be given to the creator, Only noncommercial uses for the work are permitted CC BY-NC-SA: Credit must be given to the creator, Only noncommercial uses for the work are permitted, Adaptations or derivative works must be licensed under an identical CC license CC BY-ND: Credit must be given to the creator, No derivative works/adaptations are allowed CC BY-NC-ND: Credit must be given to the creator, Only noncommercial uses for the work are permitted., No derivative works/adaptations are allowed CC0: The creator has entered the work into the public domain, Can be reused freely, Attribution or citation highly encouraged References: About CC Licenses. Available from: https://creativecommons.org/share-your-work/cclicenses/. U.S. Copyright Office - Definitions (FAQ). Available from: https://www.copyright.gov/help/faq-definitions.html.

Copyright protected materials can be reused if the reuse falls under fair use. Reach out to Allyson Mower for assistance with evaluating fair use.

If the library has licensed the material, you most likely have permission to reuse the materials. Reach out to a librarian for any questions on appropriate reuse. You can also request the library to purchase materials6.

Something to consider: Performing and documenting a fair use analysis may be difficult and time consuming. It may be easier to simply request permission from creator or copyright holder. More importantly, even if the analysis is easy and/or asking is not required, requesting use is a best practice that supports the ethical use of copyrighted works and guarantees that the rights of the creator or copyright holder are respected.

Evaluating Fair Use

Factor 17, 8 The purpose and character of use Factor 27, 8 The nature of the copyrighted work Factor 37, 8 Amount of the work reused Factor 47, 8 The effect of reuse Supports Fair Use Claim Purpose • Criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, or research  • Noncommercial/non-profit use • Limited duration of use  Character • Transformative: Uses the work in a new way for a new purpose   • Published • Primarily factual or scientific in nature (like works of nonfiction).  • A small portion of the work is reused  • The portion reused is not considered ‘heart’ of the work.   • Use of the work will not impact its market value  • Low risk of potential of use beyond the intended purpose/audience • Attribution is given to the original creator • Copyright holder cannot be identified after a reasonable search.  Ask permission Does Not Support Fair Use Claim   Purpose • Commercial use/for profit  • Ongoing use  Character • Use creates a derivative of the original work  • Non-transformative use  • Unpublished  • Primarily creative or imaginative in nature (like works of fiction)   • A large portion or the entirety of the work is reused.  • The reused portion is considered the ‘heart’ of the work  • No attribution is given to the original creator • Use impacts the market value of the work  • The work is commercially available

The best way to prevent inadvertently violating the rights of a creator is to ask for permission to use a protected work. There are five elements of asking for permission:

  1. Determine if permission is necessary: What kind of license protects the work? Is the work copyright protected, creative commons licensed, or in the public domain? If you are unsure, opt to ask for permission.
  2. Identify the owner: Look for any copyright notices because they will include the copyright owner. Some works may have multiple owners.
  3. Identify the rights you need and how long you need permission: Decide if you want to reproduce, distribute, and/or modify the work.
  4. Contact the owner and negotiate terms of use: Sometimes creators do not require payment.
  5. Get a permission agreement in writing with the full scope of permission you need, whether permission can be revoked, and with an explanation of how you will use the work.  

Download Permission Request Template

The following images show you where intellectual property licenses can be found.

A screen shot of a neuroscience article published in Neuron, a Cell journal. Under the article name and author list, the Article Info tab is selected. There is a red box with an arrow around the copyright information showing that Elsevier owns the copyright to the article. There is another red box at the bottom pointing to the link to the reuse request portal. A screen shot of an image of astrocyte development from The Cell Image Library.  Under the image under the tab labeled “License” is a red box with an arrow pointing to the creative commons license that protects this image. It has a grey box with a CC symbol and stick figure symbol with text to the right that states that the image is licensed under a attribution only license. A screen shot of a colorful vector drawing of organelles in a cell, specifically the endomembrane system. The image is from wikicommons. Under the summary tab under the image, there is a red box around the permission row showing the information that the work has entered the public domain and that the author grants anyone the right to use the work for any purpose.

In addition to considering the legal protections of creators and their works, researchers must follow ethical scientific practices. Falsification, fabrication, and plagiarism are considered research misconduct.

Reusing someone else’s work as your own without attribution can constitute research misconduct even if the work has entered the public domain and can be reused freely.

As you look for online assets, you may encounter the phrase ‘royalty free.’ Royalty free works means that creators are not required to be paid for each instance of reuse of their creative work. Royalty free does not mean that the creative work is free of copyright or legal intellectual property protections. You still must follow the rules of reuse set by authors.

  1. What is Copyright? | U.S. Copyright Office. Available from: https://www.copyright.gov/what-is-copyright/.
  2. About CC Licenses. Available from: https://creativecommons.org/share-your-work/cclicenses/.
  3. Policy 7-003: Ownership of Copyrightable Works and Related Works - Regulations Library - The University of Utah. Available from: https://regulations.utah.edu/research/7-003.php#a.III.A.
  4. U.S. Copyright Office - Definitions (FAQ). Available from: https://www.copyright.gov/help/faq-definitions.html.
  5. Policy 7-013: Copyright Policy: Copying of Copyrighted Works - Regulations Library - The University of Utah. Available from: https://regulations.utah.edu/research/7-013.php.
  6. Copyright Overview and Resources | Marriott Library. Available from: https://lib.utah.edu/research/copyright.php#collapseTwo/.
  7. U.S. Copyright Office Fair Use Index. Available from: https://www.copyright.gov/fair-use/index.html.
  8. LaMagna M. Learning Commons: Copyright: Can I use it? Fair Use & TEACH Act. Available from: https://learningcommons.dccc.edu/copyright/fairuse.
  9. The Basics of Getting Permission 2013 [updated 2013/03/27/T15:29:28-07:00]. Available from: https://fairuse.stanford.edu/overview/introduction/getting-permission/.
  10. Definition of Research Misconduct | ORI - The Office of Research Integrity. Available from: https://ori.hhs.gov/definition-research-misconduct.
  11. The Difference Between ‘Copyright Free’ and ‘Royalty Free’ 2020 [updated 2020/06/10/T17:38:59+00:00]. Available from: https://www.plagiarismtoday.com/2020/06/10/the-difference-between-copyright-free-and-royalty-free/.
Last Updated: 9/22/26